Site navigation

P sells sugar outright to Q on a condition that Q must not resell it beyond one kilometre of P’s godown. No sale of goodwill or other statutory exception is involved. Under section 27 of the Indian…

Question and options

P sells sugar outright to Q on a condition that Q must not resell it beyond one kilometre of P’s godown. No sale of goodwill or other statutory exception is involved. Under section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, what is the effect of the restraint?

  1. The restraint is valid because Q accepted it.

  2. The condition itself establishes absence of free consent.

  3. The restraint is void to the extent that it restrains Q’s lawful trade.

  4. The restraint is voidable at P’s option.

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: C - The restraint is void to the extent that it restrains Q’s lawful trade.

Section 27 makes an agreement restraining lawful trade void to that extent. The stated outright-sale restriction falls outside the goodwill exception; invalidity of the restraint does not automatically invalidate every severable part of the sale.

Practice for these exams

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Lawful object & void agreements