Site navigation

A shopkeeper pays a rival to close his shop and not reopen in the same street. Can the shopkeeper obtain an injunction to enforce the rival's promise?

Question and options

A shopkeeper pays a rival to close his shop and not reopen in the same street. Can the shopkeeper obtain an injunction to enforce the rival's promise?

  1. Yes, if the court finds it reasonable in time and area

  2. Yes, as Section 27 voids total restraints, not partial ones

  3. Yes, as the rival received consideration for the promise

  4. No, as the promise is void under Section 27 despite the payment

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: D - No, as the promise is void under Section 27 despite the payment

Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 makes void an agreement restraining a person from a lawful business, whether the restraint is total or partial, and payment does not save it (Madhub Chunder v. Rajcoomar Doss, 1874). With no sale of goodwill, no exception applies, so the promise cannot be enforced by injunction.

Practice for these exams

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Lawful object & void agreements