Site navigation

A, by letter, offers to sell his laptop to B for Rs.20,000. Without knowing A’s offer, B, by a letter, offers to buy the same laptop from A for Rs. 20,000. Here

Question and options

A, by letter, offers to sell his laptop to B for Rs.20,000. Without knowing A’s offer, B, by a letter, offers to buy the same laptop from A for Rs. 20,000. Here
  1. a binding contract comes into existence, as B’s letter is equivalent to acceptance of A’s offer
  2. no binding contract comes into existence as B’s letter is merely a cross offer
  3. no binding contract comes into existence as consideration is insufficient
  4. the Indian Contract Act is silent on such issues

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: B - no binding contract comes into existence as B’s letter is merely a cross offer
Identical offers crossing in the post (cross offers) do not create a contract, because neither is an acceptance of the other made with knowledge of it (Tinn v Hoffman). So no binding contract arises, and either party may still accept the other’s offer. The adequacy of the price does not arise, because an agreement fails for want of acceptance, not for insufficient consideration.

Practice for these exams

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Proposal, acceptance, communication & revocation