Legal Principle: Ignorance of Law is no excuse in India. Every person in India should be acquainted with the law of the land. Factual Position: Mr. A a foreigner visited Northern India during…
Question and options
Legal Principle: Ignorance of Law is no excuse in India. Every person in India should be acquainted with the law of the land.
Factual Position: Mr. A a foreigner visited Northern India during winters and was intrigued by the fact that the people burn small fires near the roadside to keep themselves warm. One evening he came out of the hotel and with the intention of helping some labourers sitting nearby asked some people to cut down a tree into small logs and then asked the labourers to light the fire and keep themselves warm. He also gave INR 150/- to the people who had cut down the tree. The police came and arrested him for having cut a tree in violation of the Environment Protection laws. He pleaded ignorance of the law and that the tree was dry and that few men needed it to keep themselves warm. Decide.
Factual Position: Mr. A a foreigner visited Northern India during winters and was intrigued by the fact that the people burn small fires near the roadside to keep themselves warm. One evening he came out of the hotel and with the intention of helping some labourers sitting nearby asked some people to cut down a tree into small logs and then asked the labourers to light the fire and keep themselves warm. He also gave INR 150/- to the people who had cut down the tree. The police came and arrested him for having cut a tree in violation of the Environment Protection laws. He pleaded ignorance of the law and that the tree was dry and that few men needed it to keep themselves warm. Decide.
- A is not liable as he is a foreigner and could not have known about the law of the land
- A is not liable but the people who cut down the tree and the labourers who enjoyed the fire are liable to be prosecuted
- A is liable as he should have known that cutting down of trees is an offence
- A is not responsible as he himself has not cut the tree down
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: C - A is liable as he should have known that cutting down of trees is an offence
The principle says ignorance of the law is no excuse and everyone in India must know the law of the land. Being a foreigner is no defence, and A caused the tree to be cut, so he is liable.
Practice for these exams
-
CUSAT CAT Five-Year LL.B.
Related question papers
Related exam syllabi
More solved explanations in Legal reasoning (principle-fact)
- The question consists of two statements, one labelled as PRINCIPLE and the other as FACT. You are to examine the principle and apply it to the given facts…
- Direction: Given below is a Legal Principle followed by a Factual Situation. Apply the principle to it and select the most appropriate answer among the four…
- This question consists of a legal proposition/principle (hereinafter referred to as ‘principle’) and facts. The principle has to be applied to the given facts to…
- Apply the principle to the facts given below and choose the most appropriate answer. Principle: The law permits citizens to use force only for protection when…
- A, a married man, has consensual sexual intercourse with B, a woman who is married to C. Which of the following correctly states the present legal position in India?