Site navigation

Legal Principle: After a proposal by the promisor has been made to the promisee and the promisee in return for a consideration accepts the proposal and communicates such acceptance so as to be out…

Question and options

Legal Principle: After a proposal by the promisor has been made to the promisee and the promisee in return for a consideration accepts the proposal and communicates such acceptance so as to be out of his control of recall, a contract enforceable by law is said to have been executed.
Factual Situation: X accesses the website of a furniture seller. He likes certain book shelf. He then calls up the furniture seller and requests further details. The furniture seller then offers to sell the bookshelf liked by X. X agrees to pay the price of the book shelf. For this purpose the furniture seller requests him to send a letter confirming their telephonic communication pertaining to purchase of bookshelf and promising payment within 7 days after the delivery of the bookshelf. X sends the letter. X does not receive the bookshelf. Furniture seller claims to have not received the letter. X seeks to enforce the agreement. Decide.
  1. Furniture seller is not liable as acceptance was not communicated
  2. Furniture seller is liable as the posted acceptance was beyond X’s power to revoke
  3. Furniture seller is not liable as the money has not been received
  4. None of the given options is correct

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: B - Furniture seller is liable as the posted acceptance was beyond X’s power to revoke
Under the stated principle, the contract is complete once acceptance is communicated so as to be out of the acceptor's power to recall it. Posting the letter put it out of X's control (the postal rule), so the contract was concluded even though the seller claims not to have received it. The seller is liable.

Practice for these exams

  • CUSAT CAT Five-Year LL.B.

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Legal reasoning (principle-fact)