LawMint Sign in

Legal Principle: A master will be liable for the wrongful acts of his servants done in the course of employment. Factual Situation: M was an old widow who opened an account with the ABC Bank whereby…

Legal Principle: A master will be liable for the wrongful acts of his servants done in the course of employment.
Factual Situation: M was an old widow who opened an account with the ABC Bank whereby she would deposit every month a sum of INR 500/-. N a neighbour who worked as the storekeeper in the Bank would collect the money from M and on payment of a small commission from M deposit the same with the Bank. One day M found out that the entire money for the period of 36 months had been appropriated by N. M filed a suit against the ABC Bank. Decide:
  1. ABC Bank would be liable because N was their employee and was supposed to be depositing the money on behalf of M
  2. ABC Bank is not liable, as N acted under a private arrangement with M, not as part of his duties
    (correct answer)
  3. The ABC Bank is morally responsible as an old widow has been duped of her life’s savings by an employee of the bank
  4. ABC Bank would be liable because N was being paid a commission by M

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: B - ABC Bank is not liable, as N acted under a private arrangement with M, not as part of his duties
Vicarious liability covers only acts done in the course of employment. N was a storekeeper with no authority to take deposits, and he collected the money under a private, commission-based arrangement with M. That is outside the course of his employment, so the bank is not liable.

Practice for these exams

  • CUSAT CAT Five-Year LL.B.