Legal Principle: A master will be liable for the wrongful acts of his servants done in the course of employment. Factual Situation: M was an old widow who opened an account with the ABC Bank whereby…
Legal Principle: A master will be liable for the wrongful acts of his servants done in the course of employment.
Factual Situation: M was an old widow who opened an account with the ABC Bank whereby she would deposit every month a sum of INR 500/-. N a neighbour who worked as the storekeeper in the Bank would collect the money from M and on payment of a small commission from M deposit the same with the Bank. One day M found out that the entire money for the period of 36 months had been appropriated by N. M filed a suit against the ABC Bank. Decide:
Factual Situation: M was an old widow who opened an account with the ABC Bank whereby she would deposit every month a sum of INR 500/-. N a neighbour who worked as the storekeeper in the Bank would collect the money from M and on payment of a small commission from M deposit the same with the Bank. One day M found out that the entire money for the period of 36 months had been appropriated by N. M filed a suit against the ABC Bank. Decide:
- ABC Bank would be liable because N was their employee and was supposed to be depositing the money on behalf of M
- ABC Bank is not liable, as N acted under a private arrangement with M, not as part of his duties(correct answer)
- The ABC Bank is morally responsible as an old widow has been duped of her life’s savings by an employee of the bank
- ABC Bank would be liable because N was being paid a commission by M
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: B - ABC Bank is not liable, as N acted under a private arrangement with M, not as part of his duties
Vicarious liability covers only acts done in the course of employment. N was a storekeeper with no authority to take deposits, and he collected the money under a private, commission-based arrangement with M. That is outside the course of his employment, so the bank is not liable.
Practice for these exams
-
CUSAT CAT Five-Year LL.B.
Related question papers
Related exam syllabi
More solved explanations in Legal reasoning (principle-fact)
- This question consists of a legal proposition/principle (hereinafter referred to as ‘principle’) and facts. The principle has to be applied to the given facts to…
- Directions: This question consists of legal principle(s) (hereinafter referred to as ‘principle’) and facts. Such proposition may or may not be true in the real…
- A puisne judge of a High Court is
- Almost all political parties participated and contributed their share in the formation of Indian Constitution. Which one of the following parties was not…
- The highest law officer in India is the