Direction: A principle and facts are given; choose the answer based on the principle and facts. PRINCIPLE: An act done in good faith for the benefit of a person without that person's consent is not…
Question and options
Direction: A principle and facts are given; choose the answer based on the principle and facts.
PRINCIPLE: An act done in good faith for the benefit of a person without that person's consent is not an offence only if it is impossible to obtain the consent of that person, or of his guardian or relatives, in time. Whoever causes death by doing a rash or negligent act commits an offence.
FACTS: A doctor with the intention of saving a terminal patient’s life decides to administer an experimental drug to the patient without informing the patient or taking consent from the patient’s relatives leading to the patient’s death.
PRINCIPLE: An act done in good faith for the benefit of a person without that person's consent is not an offence only if it is impossible to obtain the consent of that person, or of his guardian or relatives, in time. Whoever causes death by doing a rash or negligent act commits an offence.
FACTS: A doctor with the intention of saving a terminal patient’s life decides to administer an experimental drug to the patient without informing the patient or taking consent from the patient’s relatives leading to the patient’s death.
- The act shall not constitute an offence as there was no criminal intention
- The act shall not constitute an offence as there was no knowledge
- The act shall not constitute an offence as there was neither criminal intention nor knowledge
- The act constitutes an offence, as causing death by a rash or negligent act needs no criminal intention or knowledge
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: D - The act constitutes an offence, as causing death by a rash or negligent act needs no criminal intention or knowledge
Consent could have been obtained from the patient or the relatives, so the good-faith exception (Section 30 BNS, formerly Section 92 IPC) does not apply. Giving an experimental drug without consent and causing death is a rash or negligent act, an offence under Section 106(1) BNS (formerly Section 304A IPC) even without criminal intention or knowledge. So the act is an offence, and the no-intention and no-knowledge defences fail.
Practice for these exams
-
CUSAT CAT Integrated IPR Ph.D.
Related question papers
Related exam syllabi
More solved explanations in Legal reasoning (principle-fact)
- Directions: Choose the most appropriate option. 'Alibi' means a plea by an accused person that he
- The expenditure from the Consolidated Fund of India for which the approval of Parliament is not necessary, according to the Constitution of India, is called
- The question consists of two statements, one labelled as PRINCIPLE and the other as FACT. You are to examine the principle and apply it to the given facts…
- The act by members of a trade union, persuading others not to work is called as
- The given legal phrase is followed by four possible meanings. Choose the most appropriate option. ‘Punctum Temporis’ means