Site navigation

Direction: A principle and facts are given; choose the answer based on the principle and facts. PRINCIPLE: No person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence twice. FACTS: ‘A’, a…

Question and options

Direction: A principle and facts are given; choose the answer based on the principle and facts.
PRINCIPLE: No person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence twice.
FACTS: ‘A’, a kleptomaniac, was an acquaintance of ‘B’ and used to visit ‘B’s home on weekends. One day, ‘B’ was unable to find his watch after a visit from ‘A’.
Ultimately, ‘B’ informed the police about the missing watch and the persons who had been to his room. The police, among others, made a search on person of ‘A’ and found the watch in his pocket. At his trial, the Court found him guilty of theft and sentenced him to 3 months in prison. After completing his sentence, ‘A’ went to ‘B’s’ home to apologise for his conduct. After ‘A’ left, it was discovered that ‘B’s’ watch was missing. ‘B’ informed the police who located the watch from ‘A’s home. Can ‘A’ be prosecuted for theft?
  1. No, he has already been prosecuted and punished for theft and cannot be punished for the same again
  2. No, he is a kleptomaniac with a psychological disorder of stealing and therefore cannot be found guilty
  3. Yes, he can be prosecuted because he has committed two separate acts of theft
  4. Yes, he can be prosecuted because the recovery of the stolen goods in each case has been made from separate places

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: C - Yes, he can be prosecuted because he has committed two separate acts of theft
The double jeopardy bar applies only to the same offence. The second taking of the watch after release is a fresh, separate act of theft, so A can be prosecuted again.

Practice for these exams

  • CUSAT CAT Integrated IPR Ph.D.

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Legal reasoning (principle-fact)