Site navigation

Which of the following is not a circumstance of strengthening the authority of a precedent?

A "Closely divided opinion of the Court" tends to weaken rather than strengthen a precedent's authority, since a divided bench signals less settled reasoning, unlike…

Choose your answer

Which of the following is not a circumstance of strengthening the authority of a precedent?

Select one answer
Answer and explanation

Correct answer B

A "Closely divided opinion of the Court" tends to weaken rather than strengthen a precedent's authority, since a divided bench signals less settled reasoning, unlike "Approval of the decision in later cases and by the profession at large", "Evidence in the report that the issue was fully argued by counsel and the Court took time to deliberate" and the fact that "The decision has stood the test of time".

Practice for these exams

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

Related questions in this topic