Site navigation

In which 2012 Supreme Court of India decision about a BMW crash did the Court stress that a trial judge should actively seek the truth when a witness turns hostile to subvert the proceedings?

Question and options

In which 2012 Supreme Court of India decision about a BMW crash did the Court stress that a trial judge should actively seek the truth when a witness turns hostile to subvert the proceedings?

  1. Alagupandi v. State of Tamil Nadu

  2. Surajit Sarkar v. State of West Bengal

  3. State through Police Station, Lodhi Colony v. Sanjeev Nanda

  4. Gian Chand & Brothers v. Rattan Lal

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: C - State through Police Station, Lodhi Colony v. Sanjeev Nanda

In State through Police Station, Lodhi Colony v. Sanjeev Nanda (2012), arising from the 1999 BMW hit-and-run in Delhi, the Supreme Court observed that a trial judge must not be a mere spectator when witnesses turn hostile to subvert the trial. The judge should take an active part in the proceedings so as to find the truth and do justice.

Practice for these exams

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Examination of witnesses