Site navigation

Fact: A pulled B out of his classroom, gave blows on his ribs fracturing two of them and kicked him causing rupture of B’s enlarged spleen. A was not aware of this physical infirmity of B. Medical…

Question and options

Fact: A pulled B out of his classroom, gave blows on his ribs fracturing two of them and kicked him causing rupture of B’s enlarged spleen. A was not aware of this physical infirmity of B. Medical evidence showed that the injuries intentionally inflicted were, cumulatively, sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, and B died of them.
Issue: What offence, if any, A has committed?
  1. A has committed the offence of murder
  2. It is culpable homicide not amounting to murder
  3. It is neither murder nor culpable homicide
  4. The facts of the case show that it is a matter of grievous hurt

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: A - A has committed the offence of murder
A intentionally inflicted injuries that were, on the medical evidence, sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, which is murder under clause (c) of Section 101 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (formerly clause thirdly of Section 300 IPC); ignorance of B's enlarged spleen does not reduce liability (see also Explanation 1 to Section 100 BNS, formerly Explanation 1 to Section 299 IPC, on accelerating death of a person with a bodily infirmity). Therefore A has committed the offence of murder, not culpable homicide not amounting to murder or mere grievous hurt.

Practice for these exams

  • All India Bar Examination (AIBE)

    Subject revision

  • IIT Kharagpur LL.M. Entrance

    Subject revision

  • CUSAT Three-Year LL.B.

  • UGC NET Law

    Subject revision

  • CLAT PG

    Subject revision for a passage-based exam

  • CUET PG Law (LL.M.)

    Subject revision

  • AILET PG

    Subject revision

  • Supreme Court Law Clerk and Research Associate

    Subject revision

  • Bihar Judicial Services

    Subject revision

  • Uttarakhand Judicial Services

    Subject revision

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Offences affecting the human body