Site navigation

Under the rule in Foss v Harbottle, a decision of the majority on an internal matter of a company ordinarily binds dissenting shareholders. In which of the following cases may a minority shareholder…

Question and options

Under the rule in Foss v Harbottle, a decision of the majority on an internal matter of a company ordinarily binds dissenting shareholders. In which of the following cases may a minority shareholder sue despite that rule?

  1. The majority ratifies, by ordinary resolution, a procedural irregularity in a meeting notice

  2. The majority alters the articles by special resolution, in good faith, for the company's benefit

  3. The majority passes, by simple majority, a resolution that the Act reserves for a special resolution

  4. The directors make an honest business mistake that costs the company money and brings the directors no gain

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: C - The majority passes, by simple majority, a resolution that the Act reserves for a special resolution

The rule in Foss v Harbottle (1843) leaves internal matters to the majority, but it does not apply where the Act requires a special majority that has not been obtained, as Edwards v Halliwell (1950) recognised, so a member may sue. An honest business mistake without personal gain, a procedural irregularity the majority can ratify and a good-faith alteration of the articles by the required special majority are all matters for the majority, so the rule bars a minority suit on them.

Practice for these exams

  • All India Bar Examination (AIBE)

    Subject revision

  • IIT Kharagpur LL.M. Entrance

    Subject revision

  • UGC NET Law

    Subject revision

  • CLAT PG

    Subject revision for a passage-based exam

  • CUET PG Law (LL.M.)

    Subject revision

  • AILET PG

    Subject revision

  • Bihar Judicial Services

    Subject revision

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Oppression & mismanagement; class action