Site navigation

Goods are lent gratuitously for six months. The lender demands their return after three months. Relying on the loan, the borrower acted in a way that makes early return cause him a loss greater than…

Question and options

Goods are lent gratuitously for six months. The lender demands their return after three months. Relying on the loan, the borrower acted in a way that makes early return cause him a loss greater than the benefit he has had from the loan. What must the lender do under section 159 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, if he compels return?

  1. Indemnify the borrower for the amount by which the loss exceeds the benefit

  2. Indemnify the borrower for the whole of the loss caused by early return

  3. Pay nothing, but allow the borrower to keep the goods for six months

  4. Pay nothing, as a gratuitous lender may demand return at any time

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: A - Indemnify the borrower for the amount by which the loss exceeds the benefit

Section 159 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 lets the lender of a gratuitous loan demand return at any time, even before the agreed period ends. But where the borrower, on the faith of the loan, has acted so that early return would cause loss exceeding the benefit derived, the lender must indemnify him for the excess only, not for the whole loss.

Practice for these exams

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Bailment & pledge