Site navigation

Direction: A legal principle and a factual situation are given. Apply the given legal principle to the factual situation and select the most appropriate answer to the question: Legal Principle: A…

Question and options

Direction: A legal principle and a factual situation are given. Apply the given legal principle to the factual situation and select the most appropriate answer to the question:
Legal Principle: A minor is not competent to enter into a contract and the law will assume that the contract never happened and everything is returned to as it was
Factual Situation: A minor fraudulently misrepresenting her age, enters into a contract with another of the purchase of a piano. After the piano has been delivered she refused to pay price for the same contending the non existence of a legally binding contract
  1. The contract is valid and binding against the minor as the minor has misrepresented her age knowingly
  2. The contract is voidable at the option of the other party and thus the minor is liable to pay if the other party wants to carry out the obligation
  3. The contract is void and the court can direct the minor to restore the piano to the other party
  4. The contract is valid and the guardian of the minor will be liable to pay for the piano

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: C - The contract is void and the court can direct the minor to restore the piano to the other party
Per the principle (Mohori Bibee v. Dharmodas Ghose) a minor's agreement is void ab initio, so even fraudulent misrepresentation of age cannot make it valid or create estoppel. But the minor cannot keep the benefit: under the restitution principle the court can order the piano, still identifiable in her hands, to be restored. The answers calling the contract valid or voidable are wrong.

Practice for these exams

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Capacity to contract