Site navigation

A seller owns two motorcycles and offers to sell 'my motorcycle' without saying which. The seller means the first and the buyer, accepting, means the second. Nothing else resolves the difference.…

Question and options

A seller owns two motorcycles and offers to sell 'my motorcycle' without saying which. The seller means the first and the buyer, accepting, means the second. Nothing else resolves the difference. What is the legal position?

  1. The buyer's acceptance binds the seller to sell the second motorcycle

  2. A contract arises, but it is voidable at the buyer's option for misrepresentation

  3. No contract arises, as they did not agree on the same thing in the same sense

  4. The seller's meaning prevails, so the first motorcycle is sold

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: C - No contract arises, as they did not agree on the same thing in the same sense

Section 13 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 says two or more persons consent when they agree upon the same thing in the same sense. Here there is no such consensus on the subject matter, so no contract arises; there is no misrepresentation either, since neither party made a false statement of fact.

Practice for these exams

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Free consent