Site navigation

Which statement distinguishes malice in law from malice in fact when reviewing an administrative act?

Question and options

Which statement distinguishes malice in law from malice in fact when reviewing an administrative act?

  1. Malice in law concerns a deliberate wrongful act without lawful justification. Malice in fact concerns actual improper motive.

  2. Malice in law requires personal spite. Malice in fact concerns only the absence of legal authority.

  3. Both terms mean only that the act was intentional.

  4. Both terms impose an identical requirement to prove personal ill will.

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: A - Malice in law concerns a deliberate wrongful act without lawful justification. Malice in fact concerns actual improper motive.

Malice in law can arise from deliberately using a power for an unauthorised purpose or acting wrongfully without lawful justification. Personal ill will need not be proved for legal malice. Malice in fact refers to an actual improper motive.

Practice for these exams

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Judicial review of administrative action