Site navigation

Under Article 254(1), where competent Union and State laws are repugnant on a Concurrent List matter and the exception in Article 254(2) does not apply, which law prevails?

Question and options

Under Article 254(1), where competent Union and State laws are repugnant on a Concurrent List matter and the exception in Article 254(2) does not apply, which law prevails?

  1. Parliamentary law prevails only if enacted before the State law.

  2. Parliamentary law prevails only if enacted after the State law.

  3. Parliamentary law prevails whether enacted before or after the State law.

  4. The State law prevails regardless of when Parliament enacted its law.

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: C - Parliamentary law prevails whether enacted before or after the State law.

For repugnancy within the Concurrent List, Article 254(1) gives competent Parliamentary law priority whether enacted before or after the State law, to the extent of the conflict. Article 254(2) provides an exception for a State law reserved for Presidential consideration and assented to; Parliament can subsequently override it.

Practice for these exams

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Centre-State relations