Site navigation

Two parents and their two adult daughters agree to sell their shares in a jointly owned property. Their bargain is independently enforceable. The court refuses permission to sell their minor…

Question and options

Two parents and their two adult daughters agree to sell their shares in a jointly owned property. Their bargain is independently enforceable. The court refuses permission to sell their minor daughter’s separate share. The buyer otherwise qualifies for specific performance and seeks only the adult shares. Which shares may the court order the owners to convey?

  1. No shares in the property.

  2. Only the parents’ shares.

  3. Only the adult daughters’ shares.

  4. The parents’ and both adult daughters’ shares.

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: D - The parents’ and both adult daughters’ shares.

Section 12(4) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 allows the court to enforce an independently performable part of a contract where another part cannot or ought not to be specifically performed. The permission condition affects the minor’s share. On the stated facts, the court may enforce the separate bargain for the shares owned by the parents and both adult daughters.

Practice for these exams

Related question papers

Related exam syllabi

More solved explanations in Specific performance of contracts