A supplies goods from Delhi to B in Mumbai. Their contract provides that courts in Mumbai have jurisdiction over contractual disputes. A sues in Delhi, asserting a territorial basis there. The only…
Question and options
A supplies goods from Delhi to B in Mumbai. Their contract provides that courts in Mumbai have jurisdiction over contractual disputes. A sues in Delhi, asserting a territorial basis there. The only objection is territorial jurisdiction under that clause. Under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which statement is correct?
The plaint must be refused admission automatically, without consideration of any objection.
The suit may be admitted; B must raise the objection for the court to determine it.
B has an immediate appeal merely because the suit was admitted.
The Delhi High Court can use section 24 CPC to transfer this suit to a Mumbai court outside its supervisory jurisdiction.
Answer and explanation
An exclusive jurisdiction clause restricts the place of suing among courts that would otherwise have territorial jurisdiction; it does not create an inherent lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter. Such an objection is one the defendant must take, and under section 21 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 an objection to the place of suing must be raised at the earliest possible opportunity, after which the court decides it and may return the plaint under Order VII rule 10. Admitting the plaint is not an appealable order, and section 24 lets a High Court transfer suits only among courts subordinate to it, so it cannot send the suit to a Mumbai court.
Practice for these exams
-
All India Bar Examination (AIBE)
Subject revision
-
IIT Kharagpur LL.M. Entrance
Subject revision
-
Delhi Judicial Services
-
CUET PG Law (LL.M.)
Subject revision
-
Supreme Court Law Clerk and Research Associate
Subject revision
-
Bihar Judicial Services
Subject revision
-
Uttarakhand Judicial Services
Subject revision
Related question papers
Related exam syllabi
More solved explanations in CPC.02 Jurisdiction, res sub judice, res judicata & place of suing
- Assertion (A): A civil court has jurisdiction to try suits of a civil nature except those whose cognizance is expressly or impliedly barred. Reason (R): Cognizance…
- Assume all other requirements of section 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 are met. In which forum does pendency of the earlier suit leave an Indian court…
- A suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit between the same parties cannot be stayed by court,…
- Under section 9 CPC, consider suits enforcing: I. A property right. II. A civil right of worship. III. Damages for a civil wrong. Assuming no express or implied…
- All the jointly owned land in a suit for partition lies in one court district. The relief cannot be obtained entirely through the defendant's personal obedience.…