AILET UG Legal reasoning (principle-fact) Previous Year Questions
Try the preview and open any solution for a worked explanation.
AILET UG practice pack
The practice pack for AILET UG is coming soon to LawMint.
Question 1
Principle: A driver is responsible for controlling their vehicle and avoiding harm to pedestrians, unless the pedestrian acted recklessly or unlawfully.
Facts: A driver hits a pedestrian who suddenly runs across the road outside a crosswalk without looking. The driver was obeying all traffic rules.
Which of the following is correct?
Question 2
Principle: A public official must avoid conflicts of interest that could undermine public trust, even if no actual wrongdoing occurs.
Facts: A city mayor awards a major construction contract to a company owned by her cousin. She discloses the relationship publicly and follows all procurement procedures.
Apply the principle:
Question 3
Principle - Negligence may be inferred when the incident causing harm is of a kind that ordinarily does not occur without someone’s negligence, the instrumentality or control that caused the harm was under the defendant’s management, and the plaintiff did not contribute to the harm.
Fact - Anita visits a hospital for a routine check-up. While waiting in the lobby, a large ceiling fan suddenly detaches and falls, injuring her shoulder. The hospital authorities claim that the fan had been regularly serviced and no defect was known before the accident.
Applying only the given principle to the fact, is the hospital liable?
Question 4
Principle: A person who keeps or engages with hazardous or inherently dangerous substances or activities is liable for any or all harm resulting from their escape or impact, regardless of the precautions taken, unless the harm was caused by an act of God, act of a third party, or consent of the victim.
Fact: Seema owns a perfume factory that lawfully stores large quantities of chemicals used in fragrance production. One night, a sudden lightning strike causes a fire, leading to the release of toxic fumes that harm nearby residents. Seema had complied with all safety requirements and had fireproof storage facilities in place.
Applying only the given principle to the fact, is Seema liable?
Question 5
Where public safety or the protection of human life is at stake, it is justified to limit personal freedoms and privacy in order to ensure the well-being of the broader public.
Based on the above principle, which of the following actions would be justified?
Question 6
Principle: A property owner is responsible for maintaining the safety of their premises and is liable for any injuries that occur due to hazardous conditions in the premises, unless the injured party was trespassing.
Facts: Tara owns a retail store, and a heavy rainstorm caused a leak in the ceiling of the store. Tara was aware of the leak but did not have time to fix it before customers arrived the next morning. She placed a sign warning customers of the wet floor. However, Aman, who entered the store to browse, slipped on the wet floor and injured his leg. Aman did not see the warning sign.
Based on the above which of the following statements is most accurate?
Question 7
Principle: A party to a contract is responsible for fulfilling their obligations under the agreement and is liable for damages if they fail to do so.
Facts: Richa enters into a contract with a catering company, Big Bites, to provide catering services for her wedding reception. The contract specifies that Big Bites will provide food for 125 guests on a specific date. On the day of the event, Big Bites only delivers food for 75 guests due to road closure on account of VIP movement. Richa is forced to make last-minute alternate arrangements to feed the additional guests, incurring extra costs.
Question 8
Principle: A party who receives a benefit at the expense of another party is required to make restitution to prevent unjust enrichment.
Facts: Anita hires a construction company, Best Builders, to renovate her swimming pool. The contract states that Best Builders will install new water purifiers for a total cost of INR 10,000. During the renovation, Best Builders installs high-end purifiers worth INR 15,000 instead of the standard ones specified in the contract. When the project is completed, Anita enjoys the upgraded purifiers but only pays the agreed-upon amount of INR 10,000.
Question 9
Principle: Any person who publishes false statements that result in significant financial losses to a business shall be guilty of an offense.
Facts: Jatin publishes a news article claiming that a popular restaurant has been serving unsafe food. Jatin sincerely believes this to be true. The restaurant suffers significant financial losses as a result. However, it is later revealed that the statements in Jatin’s article were false.
Has Jatin committed an offence?
Question 10
Principle 1: Whoever enters into another person’s property with intent to intimidate, insult or annoy that person, commits “criminal trespass”.
Principle 2: An act which causes harm which is so slight that no person of ordinary sense and temper would complain of such harm, is deemed not to amount to intimidation, insult or annoyance.
Facts: X enters into Y’s property at midnight, uninvited, and points a gun at Y. A few minutes later, he reveals that the gun is a toy gun.
Previous papers with Legal reasoning (principle-fact) questions
AILET UG practice pack
The practice pack for AILET UG is coming soon to LawMint.