LawMint Sign in

AILET PG Parties & vicarious liability Previous Year Questions

Try the preview and open any solution for a worked explanation.

AILET PG practice pack

The practice pack for AILET PG is coming soon to LawMint.

Question 1

Apply the legal principle or principles to the given factual situation and select the most appropriate answer.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE : A master shall be liable for the acts of his servants done in the course of employment.

FACTUAL SITUATION : PAL, a public sector undertaking, is operating a number of bus services for its employees in Pune. These buses are quite distinct in their appearance and carry the board 'for PAL employees only'. M, a villager from neighboring state, was waiting for a regular bus in one of the bus stops in Pune. A bus belonging to PAL happened to stop nearby and number of people got into the bus. M, without realizing that it was PAL bus, got into the bus and soon thereafter, the bus met with an accident due to driver's negligence. M, along with several others, was injured in the accident. M seeks to file a suit against PAL claiming damages.

DECISION :

Select one answer

Question 2

Apply the legal principle or principles to the given factual situation and select the most appropriate answer.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE : In the employer — employee relationship, the employer is held liable for all the wrongs committed by his employees in the course of employment.

FACTUAL SITUATION : David was employed as a Driver in ABC & co over the past 15 years and has been appreciated by the General Manager for his hard work and sincerity. He has been rewarded by the company for his accident free record. David's younger brother wanted to join the same company as a driver. He obtained a Learner's Licence, joined a Driving School and was learning driving during the last three months. He was on the verge of completion of the training and wanted to have more practice before the driving test. He requested his brother David for using the Company's car for two days. David allowed him to use the office car for the practice. While he was practising driving, a truck came from the wrong side, hit the company's car driven by David's brother, which in turn hit a pedestrian and injured him. The pedestrian sues the company for damages.

DECISION :

Select one answer

Question 3

Apply the legal principle or principles to the given factual situation and select the most appropriate answer.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE : Employers/ Principals are vicariously liable, under the respondeat superior doctrine, for negligent acts or omissions by their employees/ agents in the course of employment/ agency. A servant/agent may be defined as any person employed by another to do work for him on the terms that he, the servant/ agent, is to be subject to the control and directions of his employer/ principal in respect of the manner in which his work is to be done.

FACTUAL SITUATION : A motor car was owned by and registered and insured in the name of A (wife) but was regarded by her and her husband (B) as "our car." B used it to go to work, and A for shopping at the weekends. B told A that if ever he was drunk and unfit to drive through, he would get a sober friend to drive him or else telephone her to come and fetch him. On the day in question the husband telephoned the wife after work and told her that he was going out with friends. He visited a number of public houses and had drinks. At some stage, he realized that he was unable to drive safely and asked a friend, C, to drive. C drove them to other public houses. After the last had been visited C offered the three friends (X, Y and Z) a lift and they got in, together with B who was in a soporific condition. C then proceeded, at his own suggestion, to drive in a direction away from B's home to have a meal. On the way, due to C's negligent driving, an accident occurred in which both B and C were killed and the other friends got injured. X, Y and Z brought an action against the wife both in her personal capacity and as administratrix of the husband's estate. Decide whether A is liable.

DECISION :

Select one answer

Question 4

A legal principle and a specific factual situation are provided in this question. Apply the principles to the given facts and select the most appropriate answer.
LEGAL PRINCIPLE :
1. Vicarious liability is when employers are held liable for the torts of their employees that are committed during the course of employment.
2. A servant is a person subject to the command of his master as to the manner in which he shall do his work. The question of whether a person is an employee depends upon the degree of control which the 'employer' exercises over the worker. FACTUAL SITUATION: Raja is a travel agent and possessed certain houses, which had an internal communication throughout, and which were used for the purpose of his business. Ramesh looked after the houses, and lived in them for this purpose, but he was also a clerk in Raja's pay at a set annual salary. He lived in the houses with his wife, a child, and a servant. The case concerned the payment of the inhabited house duty. There was a statutory exemption for premises which were occupied by a "servant" or person occupying the premises "for protection thereof". Raja was claiming the exemption from the liability by claiming that Ramesh was the servant. Using only the stated manner-of-work control test, and without assuming a right of control from salary or residence alone, which conclusion about Ramesh's status is justified by these facts?

Select one answer

Question 5

The aggrieved party suffered due to a tort committed by many wrongdoers may file a civil suit against :

1. Anyone of the wrongdoers

2. Few of the wrongdoers

3. All of the wrongdoers

Select one answer

Question 6

Depending upon the apportionment of compensation done by the court or otherwise, the aggrieved party suffered due to a tort committed by many tort-feasors may get compensation from

1. Anyone of the tort-feasors

2. Few of the tort-feasors

3. All of the tort-feasors

Select one answer

Question 7

The victim of a tort committed by joint tortfeasors may file a suit against:

I. One or some or all of the tortfeasors

II. All of the tortfeasors only

Select one answer

Question 8

‘P’ gave her expensive dress to ‘D’, a drycleaner for getting it cleaned, who in turn gave the dress to his worker ‘M’ for the purpose of cleaning. ‘M’ without permission of ‘D’ gave the dress to a lady ‘X’ for wearing on some party. ‘X’ returned the dress to M in a damaged condition. ‘P’ files suit against ‘D’ for her loss.

Select one answer

Question 9

After matching list I and II, point out the correct code.

List IList II
1. Mersey Dock’s v. Proctora. Statutory Authority
2. Metropolitan Asylum District v. Hillb. Vicarious Liability
3. Nichols v. Marslandc. Inevitable Accident
4. Holmes v. Matherd. Act of God
Select one answer

Question 10

Under the Law of Tort, a minor ______

Select one answer

Continue practising

The practice pack for AILET PG is coming soon to LawMint.

AILET PG practice pack

The practice pack for AILET PG is coming soon to LawMint.